Book Review: Kill Switch, the Rise of the Modern Senate and the Crippling of American Democracy

A majority being held hostage by a political minority. That’s the story told in Kill Switch: The Rise of the Modern Senate and the Crippling of American Democracy by Adam Jentleson, a former deputy chief of staff for the (just recently) late U.S. Senator Harry Reid.

Jentleson’s clearest example for how the modern Senate hurts and holds back America is told through the story of the “background checks” bill from 2013. In the wake of the unspeakable brutal massacre of school children and adults at Sandy Hook Elementary, the bill was a bipartisan effort that had the support of Republican Senator Pat Toomey and Democratic Senator Joe Mancin. A right-wing, 2nd Amendment rights group even supported it. 55 senators were ready to vote in favor of universal background checks for gun purchases, while 45 were not. Because of the super majority needed to end a filibuster, Republicans didn’t even have to debate it, or stand on the floor of the Senate to explain to the American people why they opposed it. As the author notes,

“it had not mattered that the opponents of the bill lost the debate in the court of public opinion by a landslide…All they needed to do was hold together a minority of senators, most of whom would not face voters at the polls for several years…they were accountable almost exclusively to people who looked and thought like they did: white conservatives.”

According to Jentleson, the bill was “supported by 90 percent of Americans.” (p. 19)

Contrast that bipartisan effort with the legislative actions by Republican-controlled legislatures across the country since former president Donald J. Trump lost, but refused to concede the 2020 election. After he led an insurrection at the Capitol on January 6th, 148 members of Congress, all Republican, voted against certifying the election results in states like my own, Pennsylvania, and Arizona. Since then, dozens of voter suppression bills have either been proposed or passed. The literature on the new Jim Crow is plentiful, with authors like Carol Anderson and Ari Berman documenting the multitude of ways in which the Republican Party makes it harder to vote. These tactics include the shutting down of hundreds of precincts since the Supreme Court gutted parts of the Voting Rights Act in 2013 as well as the inconsistent and inequitable list of acceptable forms of ID (e.g. some states allow a hunting license, while prohibiting a college ID). Even ultra-conservative Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas sided with a Court of Appeals a few years ago that had declared a voter-ID law in North Carolina violated the 14th Amendment and aimed to eliminate minority votes with “surgical precision”. Mail-in ballots are also a large target, given that many states made it universal during the pandemic, even though the red state of Utah provides for universal mail-in, something Republican Senator Mitt Romney is very proud of, but Republicans don’t bat an eyebrow in that case. The GOP has even aimed its sights at limiting who can drop-off ballots and prohibiting the vanpooling of Native Americans from reservations to polling places.

How the Filibuster Was Established

The filibuster originated via the machinations of John C. Calhoun, who as vice president under President Andrew Jackson (his first term) and president of the Senate, allowed one member after another from the minority to debate a bill that would charter the Bank of the United States, in the hopes that the Great Compromiser, Henry Clay, would miss the summer deadline. Eventually the majority would cough or make noises signaling for the filibustering members to shut up and end debate. However, the scheme had established a tactic not yet named, and “sparked a feeling of camaraderie among the minority of filibustering senators, even though they had no hope of actually defeating the bill.” (p. 51) Then, what’s called the last question rule was established that allowed a simple majority to end this intentional delay, but during the time of Woodrow Wilson in 1917, another change was made, Rule 22, which required that a super majority agree to end debate, at first 2/3rds then later reduced to what a super majority means in the Senate now, 3/5ths or 60 votes.

Though I knew that Republican obstruction in the Senate was a major problem during the Obama Years, I wasn’t aware of the extent until now. Jentleson pointed out that by the time Harry Reid had adopted the nuclear option for the purpose of presidential appointments in 2013, half of all the appointments that had been filibustered in the nation’s history occurred while Obama was president. That’s truly remarkable, and a sure sign that it is indeed the Republican Party that is the problem.

How to Define Corruption

Among the best examples of political history in the book centers around a dispute between Senators John McCain (R-Arizona) and Mitch McConnell (R-Kentucky). At the time, McCain was implicated, among other senators, in a financial and federal oversight scandal that was a clear case of multiple conflicts of interest related to a businessman named Charles Keating. As a result, and likely motivated by a level of political expediency, McCain became one of the few Republicans who believed campaign finance reform was a necessity due to what he viewed as corruption: pork barrel spending and corporate lobbying. He and Democratic Senator Diane Feingold would champion what would be known as the Bipartisan Campaign Reform Act, or McCain-Feingold for short. In 1999, Mitch McConnell called out McCain on the Senate floor, demanding that he name names to explain his general allegations of Senate corruption. (pp. 194-95) The dispute could be narrowed down to two definitions of corruption: the McConnell version, where there’s an explicit understanding that a lobbyist is handing over campaign contributions in exchange for either support or opposition to a piece of legislation, and the McCain version, which according to the author, lines up with the view of the Founders: that excessive amounts of money contributed to campaigns serve as a violation of the public trust in leaders and institutions that should put the interests of the country over their self-interest and preservation. (pp. 196-197) The Supreme Court would later side with McCain in McConnell v. FEC, but only a handful of years later, effectively overturn that decision with the disastrous Citizens United decision (2009) in which the conservative wing of the Supreme Court equated unlimited and corporate contributions to American politics with free speech.

Thoughts This Book Provoked

1. What I’ve realized is we’re a better country than the modern Senate allows.

2. One important takeaway from the book is the fact that American sentiment has often been ahead of the laws its country’s legislators have passed. Anti-lynching legislation and laws to end poll taxes were supported by a majority of Americans in the 1930s/40s, but a majority of U.S. senators were stopped by the minority’s use of the filibuster. In short, the filibuster added decades to the needless suffering of and lack of protection for Black and Brown Americans.

3. How radical it is that in the American system a person can be elected president with less than 50% of the vote, yet a simple majority in the Senate can be blocked from voting on legislation supported by an overwhelming majority of Americans by a super minority of senators, or more specifically, one objection in the form of a phone call or email.

4. You tell me how it makes any sense that the Senate requires 60 votes to end a filibuster, but the Republican Party can go nuclear on Supreme Court nominations, resulting in the confirmation of Justices Neil Gorsuch and Brett Kavanaugh with just a simple majority, 54 and 50 votes, respectively (pp. 230 and 232).

5. I’m reminded of the common refrain that “historians today are revisionist,” which might as well be an insult because it suggests that historians are lying through their coffee stained teeth. A good analogy for why this is wrongheaded begins with the famous painting titled Scene at the Signing of the Constitution of the United States. The Founders are standing in Independence Hall in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. The signing of perhaps the greatest document, second only to the Declaration of Independence, occurs. And you know what? It never happened that way. It’s a microcosm of the kind of job that historians are tasked with: uncovering the falsehoods, sharing the facts and providing real context. If that’s “revisionism,” well then, so be it.

120 Comments
child porn July 12, 2024
| | |
Book Review: Kill Switch, the Rise of the Modern Senate and the Crippling of American Democracy https://www.lamarea.es/xii-jornadas-de-arroces-y-fideuas-en-la-marea/
Cocuk pornosu July 6, 2024
| | |
Book Review: Kill Switch, the Rise of the Modern Senate and the Crippling of American Democracy https://chinergie.nl/vriendschap/
porn July 2, 2024
| | |
Book Review: Kill Switch, the Rise of the Modern Senate and the Crippling of American Democracy http://lcxhggzz.com/switch.php?m=n
porn July 2, 2024
| | |
Book Review: Kill Switch, the Rise of the Modern Senate and the Crippling of American Democracy https://theradioholic.com/podcast-desde-casa/
para que sirve cephalexin 500 mg para que sirve cephalexin 500 mg
ciprofloxacin dexamethasone ciprofloxacin dexamethasone
prednisone constipation June 27, 2024
| | |
prednisone constipation prednisone constipation
over the counter metformin over the counter metformin
how long does provigil take to start working how long does provigil take to start working
does lisinopril make you pee does lisinopril make you pee
lyrica for neuropathy June 26, 2024
| | |
lyrica for neuropathy lyrica for neuropathy
anastrozole vs tamoxifen quality of life anastrozole vs tamoxifen quality of life
side effects of flagyl June 26, 2024
| | |
side effects of flagyl side effects of flagyl
trazodone names June 26, 2024
| | |
trazodone names trazodone names
doxycycline for dogs dosage chart doxycycline for dogs dosage chart
how to take valacyclovir how to take valacyclovir
side effects of keflex in elderly side effects of keflex in elderly
amoxicillin dosage by weight amoxicillin dosage by weight
gabapentin side effects in elderly gabapentin side effects in elderly
ampicillin gram positive bacteria ampicillin gram positive bacteria
side effects of augmentin side effects of augmentin
child porn June 12, 2024
| | |
Book Review: Kill Switch, the Rise of the Modern Senate and the Crippling of American Democracy https://contentengine.ai/showcase-esports/content-engine/fortnite/08/09/2019/fortnite-update-for-the-week-ending-aug-9-adds-outposts-6v6-modes-and-other-additions/
child porn June 11, 2024
| | |
Book Review: Kill Switch, the Rise of the Modern Senate and the Crippling of American Democracy https://blog.difitek.com/best-fintech-reports-of-2017/
ananın amı June 6, 2024
| | |
Book Review: Kill Switch, the Rise of the Modern Senate and the Crippling of American Democracy https://highendmarketplace.com/history-cannabis-medicine/
animal porn June 4, 2024
| | |
Book Review: Kill Switch, the Rise of the Modern Senate and the Crippling of American Democracy https://crispol.fr/nouveau-site-internet/
vardenafil for women May 17, 2024
| | |
vardenafil for women vardenafil for women
ivermectin 400 mg brands ivermectin 400 mg brands
vardenafil hydrochloride trihydrate 20 mg vardenafil hydrochloride trihydrate 20 mg
tadalafil and tamsulosin and blood pressure tadalafil and tamsulosin and blood pressure
tadalafil mechanism May 17, 2024
| | |
tadalafil mechanism tadalafil mechanism
ivermectin 0.5% brand name ivermectin 0.5% brand name
ivermectin oral 0 8 May 17, 2024
| | |
ivermectin oral 0 8 ivermectin oral 0 8
male viagra May 17, 2024
| | |
male viagra male viagra
stromectol 0.1 May 17, 2024
| | |
stromectol 0.1 stromectol 0.1
viagra pills cheap online viagra pills cheap online
ivermectin cream May 17, 2024
| | |
ivermectin cream ivermectin cream
ivermectin gel May 17, 2024
| | |
ivermectin gel ivermectin gel
sex historie May 15, 2024
| | |
Book Review: Kill Switch, the Rise of the Modern Senate and the Crippling of American Democracy https://aahanatheblisstore.com/product/purplebliss-vanaspati-ghee-instadiyas-with-sandal-essential-oils-copy/
sildenafil and nitroglycerin sildenafil and nitroglycerin
online sildenafil May 13, 2024
| | |
online sildenafil online sildenafil
superdrug pharmacy cialis superdrug pharmacy cialis
tadalafil 5mg generic May 13, 2024
| | |
tadalafil 5mg generic tadalafil 5mg generic
cialis online pills May 13, 2024
| | |
cialis online pills cialis online pills
online pharmacy no perscription online pharmacy no perscription
buy levitra cialis May 13, 2024
| | |
buy levitra cialis buy levitra cialis
will levitra work if viagra doesn't will levitra work if viagra doesn't
child porn May 4, 2024
| | |
Book Review: Kill Switch, the Rise of the Modern Senate and the Crippling of American Democracy https://www.enbigi.com/update-perolehan-medali-olimpiade-tokyo-2020-senin-26-juli-2021/
child porn May 3, 2024
| | |
Book Review: Kill Switch, the Rise of the Modern Senate and the Crippling of American Democracy https://voxpop.ch/hallo-welt/
child porn April 30, 2024
| | |
Book Review: Kill Switch, the Rise of the Modern Senate and the Crippling of American Democracy https://writingspot.org/how-to-choose-the-right-car-paint-protection-wrap-for-lasting-results/
grandpashabet April 27, 2024
| | |
Book Review: Kill Switch, the Rise of the Modern Senate and the Crippling of American Democracy https://thegioibiaruou.com/san-pham/bia-trappistes-rochefort-8/
ivermectin price comparison ivermectin price comparison
tamsulosin hydrochloride 400 micrograms side effects tamsulosin hydrochloride 400 micrograms side effects
tizanidine uses April 19, 2024
| | |
tizanidine uses tizanidine uses
synthroid synthesis April 19, 2024
| | |
synthroid synthesis synthroid synthesis
venlafaxine liver damage April 19, 2024
| | |
venlafaxine liver damage venlafaxine liver damage
does spironolactone cause weight loss does spironolactone cause weight loss
sitagliptina y sitagliptina sitagliptina y sitagliptina
voltaren vs tylenol April 19, 2024
| | |
voltaren vs tylenol voltaren vs tylenol
porn April 15, 2024
| | |
Book Review: Kill Switch, the Rise of the Modern Senate and the Crippling of American Democracy https://www.agtecnology.net/category/uncategorized/
robaxin 750 mg street price robaxin 750 mg street price
acarbose esrd April 14, 2024
| | |
acarbose esrd acarbose esrd
kidney pain semaglutide April 14, 2024
| | |
kidney pain semaglutide kidney pain semaglutide
repaglinide molecular weight repaglinide molecular weight
remeron dose for sleep April 14, 2024
| | |
remeron dose for sleep remeron dose for sleep
abilify indications April 14, 2024
| | |
abilify indications abilify indications
actos verschreibung April 14, 2024
| | |
actos verschreibung actos verschreibung
protonix and zantac April 14, 2024
| | |
protonix and zantac protonix and zantac
aripiprazole lauroxil March 25, 2024
| | |
aripiprazole lauroxil aripiprazole lauroxil
amitriptyline 25 mg March 25, 2024
| | |
amitriptyline 25 mg amitriptyline 25 mg
children's aspirin March 24, 2024
| | |
children's aspirin children's aspirin
allopurinol gout flare March 24, 2024
| | |
allopurinol gout flare allopurinol gout flare
is flomax a sulfa based drug is flomax a sulfa based drug
take contrave with or without food take contrave with or without food
depakote side effects elderly depakote side effects elderly
how long does cozaar stay in your system how long does cozaar stay in your system
citalopram anti depressants citalopram anti depressants
ezetimibe solubility in water ezetimibe solubility in water
ddavp medication dosage March 22, 2024
| | |
ddavp medication dosage ddavp medication dosage
amoxicillin vs augmentin March 22, 2024
| | |
amoxicillin vs augmentin amoxicillin vs augmentin
diclofenac sodium 75mg dr tablets diclofenac sodium 75mg dr tablets
diltiazem er 180 mg March 22, 2024
| | |
diltiazem er 180 mg diltiazem er 180 mg
over the counter flexeril over the counter flexeril
how to tell if effexor is working how to tell if effexor is working
amoxicillin with or without food amoxicillin with or without food
neurontin law suit March 22, 2024
| | |
neurontin law suit neurontin law suit
porno izle March 10, 2024
| | |
Book Review: Kill Switch, the Rise of the Modern Senate and the Crippling of American Democracy http://www.institutlluiscompanys.org/presentacio-de-les-tutories-per-a-les-families-de-4t-deso-i-de-batxillerat/
will bactrim treat strep February 28, 2024
| | |
will bactrim treat strep will bactrim treat strep
bactrim ds for uti February 28, 2024
| | |
bactrim ds for uti bactrim ds for uti
can i take cephalexin if i'm allergic to penicillin can i take cephalexin if i'm allergic to penicillin
ciprofloxacin for diverticulitis ciprofloxacin for diverticulitis
porn February 26, 2024
| | |
Book Review: Kill Switch, the Rise of the Modern Senate and the Crippling of American Democracy https://www.woodnature.es/galeria/
child porn February 25, 2024
| | |
Book Review: Kill Switch, the Rise of the Modern Senate and the Crippling of American Democracy https://quasil.in/prevent-bad-breath-toothaches-with-quasil-tm-xxxtra-strong/
porn February 25, 2024
| | |
Book Review: Kill Switch, the Rise of the Modern Senate and the Crippling of American Democracy https://www.hypnosetriplex.de/hypnose-mentaltraining-im-alltag-effizient-anwenden/
porno izle February 25, 2024
| | |
Book Review: Kill Switch, the Rise of the Modern Senate and the Crippling of American Democracy http://sign-agora.fr/2013/03/23/the-field/
how to buy viagra online safely how to buy viagra online safely
duloxetine and diazepam February 13, 2024
| | |
duloxetine and diazepam duloxetine and diazepam
lexapro impotence February 11, 2024
| | |
lexapro impotence lexapro impotence
astinenza gabapentin February 11, 2024
| | |
astinenza gabapentin astinenza gabapentin
how long does cephalexin take to work for skin infection how long does cephalexin take to work for skin infection
keflex cephalexin February 9, 2024
| | |
keflex cephalexin keflex cephalexin
can cymbalta make you tired February 9, 2024
| | |
can cymbalta make you tired can cymbalta make you tired
flagyl names February 8, 2024
| | |
flagyl names flagyl names
does fluoxetine suppress appetite does fluoxetine suppress appetite
zoloft indications February 7, 2024
| | |
zoloft indications zoloft indications
difference entre citalopram et escitalopram difference entre citalopram et escitalopram
buy liquid tadalafil January 27, 2024
| | |
buy liquid tadalafil buy liquid tadalafil
20bet October 5, 2023
| | |
I am currently writing a paper that is very related to your content. I read your article and I have some questions. I would like to ask you. Can you answer me? I'll keep an eye out for your reply. 20bet
20bet September 22, 2023
| | |
Your article gave me a lot of inspiration, I hope you can explain your point of view in more detail, because I have some doubts, thank you.
20bet September 15, 2023
| | |
Your article gave me a lot of inspiration, I hope you can explain your point of view in more detail, because I have some doubts, thank you.
Your point of view caught my eye and was very interesting. Thanks. I have a question for you. https://www.binance.com/cs/register?ref=OMM3XK51
User Login June 7, 2023
| | |
The point of view of your article has taught me a lot, and I already know how to improve the paper on gate.oi, thank you. https://www.gate.io/fr/signup/XwNAU
Cryptocurrency Prices April 18, 2023
| | |
Thanks for sharing. I read many of your blog posts, cool, your blog is very good.
Binance Sign Up Bonus April 18, 2023
| | |
Your point of view caught my eye and was very interesting. Thanks. I have a question for you.
Thank you for your sharing. I am worried that I lack creative ideas. It is your article that makes me full of hope. Thank you. But, I have a question, can you help me?
Moments sur gate.io March 26, 2023
| | |
Reading your article has greatly helped me, and I agree with you. But I still have some questions. Can you help me? I will pay attention to your answer. thank you.
Reading your article helped me a lot and I agree with you. But I still have some doubts, can you clarify for me? I'll keep an eye out for your answers.
gateio March 9, 2023
| | |
I have read your article carefully and I agree with you very much. This has provided a great help for my thesis writing, and I will seriously improve it. However, I don't know much about a certain place. Can you help me?
cryft coin price February 26, 2023
| | |
Reading your article helped me a lot and I agree with you. But I still have some doubts, can you clarify for me? I'll keep an eye out for your answers.
myhome February 14, 2023
| | |
I agree with your point of view, your article has given me a lot of help and benefited me a lot. Thanks. Hope you continue to write such excellent articles.
Hold Porn January 26, 2022
| | |
First time here, haha